Mon, 09 Jan 2006
|
Join The Debate: Disecton In Schools
Do you agree with cutting up an animal? Do you
think that it is vital for education? Do you
cringe at the sightof blood? Join the debate.
Posted 16:03
|
14 comments
|
Disection is horrible
I think disection is horrible, it is the main
reason that I dislike biology so much. Remember,
biology is the study of life, not death.
|
I Agree
Hi Rachel. I agree. I remember in Biology when
the teacher cut open the sheeps heart. Me and
you sat at the back and didn't watch. Oh, it was
awful. They say that disection teaches us. What
does it teach us? That it's right to cut up
animals? There are other ways to teach and these
schools who disect are just using the evil (and
expencive) way.
|
Couldn't agree more James
I agree James, the lungs and the heart were
definetly the most horrible things I've ever laid
eyes upon, and I wasn't even watching (sat at
back with you)I just accidently caught a glimpse
now and again. It was mean and unnessesary!
|
...
Um guys, "schools who disect are evil" are you
calling our school evil?
|
Yes, Carl, he is, it is.
I don't get it: they show us diagrams, they go
over the whole thing again and again and again,
then they take a heart that, honestly, the sheep
needs more than we do, and cut it up, just to
say "see, I was telling the truth!" I don't care
what a cross-section of my heart looks like, all
I know is it might stop a few times, but what
the hey! Who actually cares, when it comes to
it?! All cutting it up does is make squeamish
people sick, psycopaths extatic and hyper, and a
sheep ghost think "I suppose that's that then."
Nobody cares how it works, just that it does!!!
|
Except...
heart surgeons
|
Disection is evil. if they really want to know
how to treat a human. Did up a gosh darn dead
human!!!
|
Yeah...I was asked to cut up a sheep's heart in
science in yr 7 and i refused to do it and
walked out the class. I don't agree with using
animals unnecesarily (i cant spell!) when there
are perfectly good diagrams to use.
|
Yes
We already know all this knowledge anyway, I not
happy about that, bu we have to constantly cut
up more animals, as Rick says, just to prove
that it's true. It's evil and barbaric.
|
kill
i think we should slit the guts off every single
thing u disect
|
dont kill
i think we should not slit the guts off every
single thing u disect
|
I think that disection is mean, however it did
help me understand the heart a bit more. I
didn't like the lungs though. I was a bit upset,
but Ms said that the animals used were from a
slaughter house, so really its kind of a good
thing, using things that would otherwise be
thrown away to teach us about hearts and lungs.
I would rather use something from a dead animal
to teach us to help other animals (humans
included) rather than bin it. I think that
killing an animal for meat and wasting its
organs etc. is worse than teaching us about
them. At least the dead animals organs were put
to some use, so in that was I am for disection
of organs in schools from animals from a
slaughter house.
|
and they dont not use slaughter house animals
cos' it would cost alot. If I were an animal and
I was killed for meat I would prefer my organs
to go to a school to teach others about the
heart. Infact when I die I want my organs to go,
that why I have donated them all. And I think
I'll leave my body for science or something
perhaps, cos it might aswell be used rather than
buried in a hole, in a box, that has wasted wood
and taken up ground space, plus I wouldn't want
to be cremated cos' it freaks me out. (a little
of the subject there)
|
It's Better, But Still Not Good
Why do we constantly need to do this anyway. The
first time they did, they recorded, as the
second time and so on. We already have the
records, exact drawings, done the studying yet
still, every year in Year 9 in our school
another sheep is cut into. Every year, when it
is unecessary. It is better from the
slaughterhouse, but why was it there in the
first place. I think that if people really care
about animals and don't want them to die, be
tested on, be disected ETC they should become
vegetarian. As Viva say, and this is a
quote: 'The only way to save animals is to stop
eating them.'
|
Post a Comment:
|
|
|
